What if Mississippi could skip party primaries by allowing state lawmakers to pick candidates?

This column was going to start with a scathing yet still somehow funny comment about the competition to succeed Senator Thad Cochran.

While I was trying to figure out how to manage that, I remembered my recent pledge to present only positive vibes during the 40-plus days of Lent. So I scrapped the idea.

Still, with that Senate race in mind, I call your attention to a legislative proposal in Tennessee introduced in bills by Senator Frank Niceley and Representative Susan Lynn.

“This is probably the most important bill that I’ve ever brought in front of this body,” Niceley said when presenting his version in committee last week. “This bill could save the free world.”

With an intro like that, you might expect the bill to miraculously turn swords into plowshares, end hunger, or mandate free beer at baseball games. It does not.

What it proposes instead is simply to eliminate party primaries for U.S. Senate elections in Tennessee and give the power to select Republican and Democratic candidates to—state legislators.

“Now the naysayers at first say, You’re taking away my right to vote,” Niceley told committee members. “I say, No, I’m giving you your Constitution back.”

Then followed a bit of a history lesson, with Niceley describing how the Progressive Movement in “19-and-13” instituted various government changes, including adding the federal income tax and creating the Federal Reserve.

“The worst thing they did, they changed the way that we selected U.S. senators,” he said. Prior to that, the Constitution entrusted that duty to state legislators.

“That gave the states some control over what Washington did,” Niceley said.

Since states lost that power through the 17th Amendment, he said, it’s been a downhill road for the country, with runaway inflation, the Great Depression, $21 trillion in debt, and women voting. (He didn’t actually mention women voting. He may have thought it. I can’t say.)

In any event, under either bill, joint party caucuses of the Tennessee House and Senate would select their party’s Senate nominee from a list of aspirants compiled by a means to be determined later.

Minor party candidates could still qualify in the usual way, with the election in November. The benefits, Niceley said, would include saving all the time and money now invested in the primary process.

The Founding Fathers, he said, knew that if they failed in their mission to create a new country they would not only be hanged, but tortured. Still, he added, they had the nerve to try.

“And I wonder sometimes, do we have enough nerve to do this,” he asked. “They gave us the power to do this; this is perfectly constitutional.

“Do we have the nerve to take back our Constitution?”

Apparently, no. Niceley’s bill to save the free world did not make it out of committee. Nor did Lynn’s in the House.

But I invite your consideration of how the same idea might play out in Mississippi. What if we could avoid the coming months of infighting and backbiting? For that matter, what if we could have avoided the bitter Republican battle for the Senate in 20-and-14, as Niceley might express it?

I point out here that Mississippi is among the states that have never voted to adopt the 17th Amendment.

You will note the absence of any opinion from me. I call your attention again to that Lenten pledge to play nice.

A pledge that expires next Sunday.

 

News

‘Active death investigation’ launched after remains found by hunter last November identified

News

Joint Mississippi operation nets 14 arrests, discovery of loaded AR-15 style rifle and other illegal weapons

News

Mississippi man charged with girlfriend’s murder after body found in yard by passerby

News

Mississippi lake is producing record-breaking catches in 2024 — including monster catfish in April

News

Mississippi detainee found dead in county jail holding cell

News

‘Green hydrogen’ company looks to use Mississippi salt domes to become leader in burgeoning industry

News

Mississippi man killed after motorcycle crash on rural Mississippi highway

News

Mississippi man arrested in connection with 2023 commercial burglary

News

State officials say cause of propane tank explosion that killed four is ‘undetermined.’ Lawsuit against gas company moves forward.

News

Despite medical marijuana card, Mississippi man arrested on possession with intent to distribute charges. Passenger in car arrested, as well.

News

Mississippi city official fired after reportedly being found using fuel card that was to have been confiscated

News

Mississippi, Louisiana animal advocates alarmed after shopping cart full of puppies found beside dumpster

News

Forget porch pirate — suspect in custody after stealing entire Amazon van, wrecking it 40 miles away, officials say

News

Mississippi man wearing ankle monitor arrested after reportedly breaking into garage

News

Woman pleads guilty to embezzling thousands from a Mississippi high school band’s booster account

News

Mississippi man among those granted clemency by President Biden Wednesday

News

Police: Investigation underway after passerby stumbles upon dead body in yard of Mississippi residence

News

Trailblazer for women engineers for 60 years gives $5 million to her Mississippi alma mater

News

Police say product being sold in Mississippi smoke shops is so similar to cannibis that they cannot discern the difference

News

29-year-old Mississippi man dies after fiery three-vehicle wreck

News

Two in custody in connection with death of Mississippi man whose brother was shot, killed last month

News

Mississippi judge finds woman guilty of trespassing on land for controversial proposed oilfield landfill owned by county supervisor

News

Mississippi man arrested for reportedly fighting, spitting on police during Morgan Wallen concert

News

Mississippi police looking for man who reportedly killed girlfriend by running over her several times